top of page

Should Your Salon Do Black Friday? What a Discount Really Costs

Nov 10
9 min read

Updated: 23 hours ago

Only if your numbers say yes. Take a $120 service. After product, commission and card fees, 20% off cuts what the salon keeps from that appointment by about a quarter, so you need about a third more bookings just to break even. If your chairs are already full, a discount usually costs more than it brings in.


Most salon Black Friday advice comes from booking-software companies, and it's about ideas: flash sales, gift card deals, social posts. Very little of it does the money math, and that's what you need, because a promotion that fills the book can still leave you with less money than an ordinary week.


What a 20% discount really costs a salon


Here is one service, priced at $120, run through with simple, round assumptions. Swap in your own numbers as you read.


  • Service price: $120.

  • Product cost: $12 of color and backbar product (10% of the full price). The product doesn't get cheaper because the price did, so it stays at $12.

  • Stylist pay: 40% commission on the price the client pays.

  • Card fees: 3% of whatever the client pays.



Full price

20% off, commission on the price paid

20% off, commission on the full price

Client pays

$120.00

$96.00

$96.00

Product

$12.00

$12.00

$12.00

Stylist commission

$48.00

$38.40

$48.00

Card fee (3%)

$3.60

$2.88

$2.88

Left for rent, wages and profit

$56.40

$42.72

$33.12


At full price, the appointment leaves the salon $56.40 to put toward rent, the front desk, insurance and, eventually, profit. At 20% off, that drops to $42.72. The salon gives up $13.68 per discounted service, about 24% of what it would normally keep.


Look at who pays for the rest of the discount. When commission is paid on the discounted price, your stylist earns $9.60 less for the same work. That's a real cost too, just not one that shows up on your P&L. Some owners protect their team by paying commission on the full price. That's generous, and it puts the whole discount on the salon: the salon keeps $33.12, which is $23.28 less than at full price, a drop of about 41%.


This example leaves out payroll taxes, the time a service takes and anything else that's specific to your salon, so your own figures will be different. If you don't know your product cost per service, start with product cost percentage in a salon and why it drifts. If you don't know which services earn the most per hour, which of your services actually make money walks through it.


How many extra bookings it takes to break even


To find out, divide what's left at full price by what's left at the discounted price. The answer tells you how many discounted bookings it takes to equal one full-price booking.


  • Commission on the price paid: $56.40 ÷ $42.72 = 1.32. Ten full-price bookings leave $564. To match that at 20% off, you need 13.2 bookings, so 14 in practice. That's about 32% more appointments for the same money.

  • Commission on the full price: $56.40 ÷ $33.12 = 1.70. You need 17.03 bookings, so 18 in practice, to match ten full-price ones. That's about 70% more.


And those extra bookings have to be new bookings. Every regular who would have come in anyway at full price, and simply booked during the sale, costs you the $13.68 with nothing gained in return.


Timing makes this harder. For most salons, late November and December are already the busiest weeks of the year. Phorest data from more than 6,000 salons, mostly in the UK and Ireland, shows December bringing in over 10% of a salon's yearly revenue (Salon Today). If your book is full, there's no room for 32% more appointments. Each discounted booking simply replaces a full-price one. For the bigger picture, here's the break-even point for a service business: how many clients you need each month to cover your costs.


If you do the service yourself


A solo owner or independent stylist pays no commission, so the numbers look different, but the answer doesn't change much. At full price, the same $120 service leaves you $104.40 after product and card fees. At 20% off, it leaves $81.12. You'd need about 29% more bookings (12.9 for every 10) to come out even. Each discounted appointment also pays you $23.28 less for the same time in the chair.


The costs that don't show up in the math


The table only counts one appointment. A blanket discount has other costs that are harder to put a number on.


  • You discount the clients who'd have paid full price. Your regulars see the sale too. A discount aimed at everyone mostly reaches people who were already coming.

  • Clients learn to wait. Discount every November, and some clients will start holding their color appointment until the sale comes around. A stylist quoted in industry commentary put the worry simply: clients start asking why you can't discount every time.

  • Your team works harder for less. More bookings at lower commission is a hard sell in the busiest month of the year.

  • It works against your prices. If you're planning a January price rise, a deep November discount sends the opposite message. Here is what a price rise does to what you actually keep.


What a gift card deal really means


Gift card deals are the most popular salon Black Friday idea, and they look painless because the money arrives right away. Two common versions are "a $100 gift card for $80" and "buy a $100 gift card, get a $25 bonus card." Both are really a 20% discount on services you'll deliver later.


Here they are with the same assumptions as above, except that commission is paid on the full value of the service the stylist delivers. Card fees are paid once, when the gift card is bought.


Promotion

Cash in, after card fee

Service delivered

Product and commission

Left over

A $100 service at full price

$97.00

$100

$50.00

$47.00

$100 gift card sold for $80

$77.60

$100

$50.00

$27.60

$100 card plus a $25 bonus card

$97.00

$125

$62.50

$34.50


The bonus card looks better because more cash comes in. Per $100 of service delivered, though, it works out the same: $34.50 for $125 of work is $27.60 per $100, exactly like the $80 card. Either way, you keep about 41% less than you would from a full-price appointment.


Gift card deals have a timing problem too. The cash comes in during November and December, and much of the work often comes back in January, when bookings are slower and the bills haven't changed. You still pay commission and product on every redeemed card, with no new money coming in. Until a card is redeemed, its cash is money you owe in future services, not money you've earned. The safest habit is to move gift card sales into a separate account and move them back only as cards are used. Here's how many bank accounts a small business needs.


Bonus cards also have their own rules. Under federal rules, the money on a gift card someone pays for can't expire within five years of when it was bought or last loaded. Cards given away free as part of a promotion are treated differently, but they still need their terms printed on them, and your state may have rules of its own. Check before you put an end date on any card.


Better alternatives to a Black Friday discount


You don't have to sit out the season to protect your margin. These options cost less, and some of them help in January rather than hurt.


Bundle retail, or clear slow-moving stock


Retail doesn't use chair time, and a gift with purchase costs you what you paid for it, not its shelf price. Say you buy retail at half its shelf price. A $40 shampoo and a $40 conditioner cost you $40 together.


  • 20% off both: the client pays $64, and you keep $24.

  • Both at full price, plus a free $16 travel-size styler that cost you $8: the client pays $80, and you keep $32.


The bundle feels generous to the client and leaves you $8 more than the discount (before card fees and any retail commission). If you have products that have sat on the shelf for months, a real discount on those makes sense. That stock is cash you've already spent, and selling it, even at a smaller margin, turns it back into cash.


Bonus cards that only work in quiet weeks


If you do offer a bonus card, make it redeemable only in January and February, when chairs are more likely to sit empty. Treatwell, a salon booking platform, suggests this approach. The service still costs you product and commission when the card is used, but it lands in weeks you'd struggle to fill anyway, and it brings clients back during the slow stretch. Pair it with the rest of your slow season plan.


Rebooking incentives


Reward the behavior you want: a booked next appointment. Offer a small add-on, such as a conditioning treatment or a gloss, to clients who book their next visit before they leave. If the add-on uses $4 of product and a few minutes, that's a much smaller cost than $13.68 off every service, and it only goes to clients who commit to coming back. Prebooking January appointments at December checkout is one of the most useful versions of this.


Client appreciation instead of a sale


A handwritten card, a small gift or a thank-you evening for your regulars costs far less than a storewide discount and doesn't teach anyone to wait for a sale. If you give clients gifts, the IRS lets you deduct no more than $25 per person per year for business gifts, so keep them modest and keep the receipts. This is general education, not tax advice. A CPA or Enrolled Agent can tell you how the rules apply to you.


When a Black Friday promotion can make sense


A discount isn't always a mistake. It can make sense when:


  • You have empty chairs in the weeks the promotion covers. A new salon, a stylist building her book, or a booth renter with gaps is filling time that would otherwise earn nothing.

  • It's aimed at new clients, not regulars. A first-visit offer with a plan to rebook can pay off if those clients come back at full price.

  • It moves retail you're overstocked on. That's cash sitting on a shelf.

  • You've run your own numbers. You know what's left per service at the sale price, and you've checked that you can realistically get the extra bookings.


If your stylists rent booths, they set their own prices, so the service math is theirs to do. Your levers are retail and the salon's own promotions. Here is what booth rent and commission each really cost you.


Run your own numbers before you decide


All you need is a calculator:


  1. Pick the service you'd discount most often.

  2. Write down its price, its product cost, what you pay the stylist and your card fee rate.

  3. Work out what's left at full price and at the sale price.

  4. Divide the first by the second. That's how many discounted bookings it takes to equal one full-price booking.

  5. Ask honestly whether you have the open appointments and the new clients to get there.


If the answer is no, choose one of the alternatives above. If you'd like a wider view of your margins first, here's how to calculate your profit margin.


Frequently asked questions


Should my salon do Black Friday?


Only if the numbers work for your salon. A 20% discount on a typical service cuts what the salon keeps by around a quarter, so you need roughly a third more bookings to break even. If you're already busy in late November, a discount usually just replaces full-price bookings. Retail bundles or quiet-week bonus cards are often better.


What are good Black Friday ideas for a salon that don't involve discounting services?


Retail bundles with a gift with purchase, bonus cards redeemable only in January and February, a free add-on for clients who prebook, and a thank-you event or small gift for regulars. Each costs less than a service discount and doesn't teach clients to wait for a sale.


Is a gift card promotion better than a discount?


Not on margin. "A $100 card for $80" and "a $25 bonus card with a $100 card" both work out to 20% off services you'll deliver later. They do bring cash in early, but that cash is owed back in future appointments, often in slow January. Treat it as money you're holding, not money you've earned.


Is discounting bad for my salon?


Not always, but a blanket discount usually is. It goes to regulars who would have paid full price, it can train clients to wait for sales, and in commission salons it cuts your stylists' pay. A targeted offer that fills genuinely empty chairs, or brings in new clients who rebook at full price, can be worth it.


How many extra clients do I need to make a 20% discount worth it?


Divide what you keep from a full-price service by what you keep at the discounted price. In this example, that's $56.40 ÷ $42.72, or about 1.32, so you need about 32% more bookings to come out even. If you pay commission on the full price, it's about 70% more.


Decide with your numbers, not the salon down the street


Donna is hosting a free live Preview on Saturday 21 November, a walkthrough of what's coming. Nothing is sold on the call. Register for the free Preview.


Knowing what each service really leaves you is what makes a calm "no" to Black Friday possible, or a confident "yes." If you'd like a place to keep those numbers, the Money Mastery System brings together five connected workbooks, Clarity AI, and the Money Mastery Collective, a community of people doing the same work beside you. Start free with La Soglia.


Full disclosure: the Money Mastery System is Donna Roggio's own product.

Related Posts

See All

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page