top of page

"Your Business Is Your Best Investment": Is It True?

Oct 30
5 min read

Updated: 22 hours ago

"Invest in your business, it is the best return you will ever get" is repeated in every room where owners gather. Sometimes it is true by a very wide margin. Sometimes it is the reason an owner reaches sixty with a well equipped business and no savings.


The trouble with the phrase is that it treats every dollar spent on the business as an investment. Some are. Many are costs with a flattering name.


Here is a one sentence test that tells them apart, the same $6,000 spent three ways, and how to hold both ideas at once.


Personal and business money side by side in the Money Mastery System

Money put into the business and money kept outside it do different jobs. Example data.


The short version


  • Spending on your business can return far more than savings ever will.

  • It can also return nothing, and it is rarely measured.

  • The test: can you say what it will bring in or save, and by when?

  • Do both. Back the business where the sum works, and keep saving outside it every year.


The test


Before any large business purchase, write one sentence and fill in both blanks.


"This will bring in or save about $____ a year, starting by ____."


If you can fill them in with figures you believe, it is an investment and you can compare it with anything else. If you cannot, it may still be worth buying. It is simply not an investment, and it should not be paid for with money that was meant for your future.


$6,000, three ways


What the $6,000 buys

The sentence

A year

Paid back in

Equipment that saves three hours a week

Three more billable hours at $75, for 48 weeks

$10,800

About 7 months

A course and a rebrand

Two new regular clients a year, each worth $855

$1,710

About 3 and a half years

A retirement contribution

Left for 15 years at an assumed 6%

Grows to about $14,400

Not spent


The first row is why the phrase exists. Equipment that gives back three hours a week returns the whole $6,000 in about seven months and keeps paying after that. No savings account comes close.


The second row is why the phrase is dangerous. It was just as easy to describe as "investing in my business", it felt just as responsible, and it takes three and a half years to pay for itself, if the two clients arrive at all.


The third row is slower than the first and far more dependable than the second. The 6% is an assumption and not a promise.


What the phrase leaves out


  1. All of it sits in one place. Money in your business and your income from your business fail together. A bad year hurts both at once.

  2. It may not be sellable. Equipment loses value, and a business built around you may have no buyer, as we set out in why your business is not a retirement plan.

  3. The return is seldom checked. Few owners go back a year later to see whether the purchase did what was claimed.

  4. It is very pleasant to spend on. New tools and a new look feel like progress, which is not the same as being progress.


A Profit and Loss report in the Money Mastery System

A year later, the report shows whether the purchase did what it promised. Example data.


When the business really is the best use


It usually is when

It usually is not when

It removes a limit on how much you can earn

It makes the business look better

The sum works within a year or two

You cannot fill in the sentence

You have used something similar before and it paid

A seller told you it would

Your cushion and tax are already covered

It comes out of money for tax or retirement


The last row matters as much as the others. A good investment paid for with your tax set-aside is still a problem in April.


A simple way to hold both


  1. Tax and cushion first. They are not available for anything else.

  2. A share to retirement, every year. Even in years when the business is hungry.

  3. Then back the business, where the sentence can be completed.

  4. Write the sentence down and check it in twelve months. That one habit improves every later decision.


The order matters. Putting retirement second means it happens in the years you least feel like it, and those are usually the years the business is taking everything.


So, is it true?


For the right purchase, completely. A business owner has access to returns that an employee simply does not, and it would be a mistake to ignore them.


As a general rule, no. "Your business is your best investment" becomes true one purchase at a time, when the sum has been done. The rest of the time it is a reason to keep saving somewhere else as well.


See both lines, free


La Soglia, the free membership of the Money Mastery System, holds everything you own and everything you owe in one place, personal and business together, with no bank connection and no card. Seeing how much of what you have sits inside the business, and how much outside it, is the quickest check on this whole question.


Bring it to the Collective


What is the best thing you ever bought for your business, and the worst? The Money Mastery Collective has a discussion feed open on the free membership. Both answers are useful to someone.


Questions we hear


Is investing in my business better than saving for retirement?

For a purchase with a clear, quick return it can be. As a general rule it is risky, because your savings and your income would then depend on the same thing.

How do I know if a business purchase is an investment?

Write down what it will bring in or save each year, and by when. If you cannot, it is a cost and not an investment.

Should I reinvest all my profit in my business?

It is safer not to. Cover tax and a cushion, keep a share for retirement each year, and reinvest where the return is clear.

What is a good return on a business purchase?

One that pays for itself within a year or two is strong. In the example, equipment saving three hours a week pays back in about seven months.


References


There are no outside figures in this post. Every number is our own worked example, and the growth figure assumes 6% a year as an illustration.


Start free with La Soglia


La Soglia is the free membership of the Money Mastery System. It gives you the Net Worth Tracker, where everything you own and everything you owe sits in one place, and the Money Mastery Collective. There is no card to enter and no bank connection.



Keep in touch


Donna shares a short version of posts like this one on Instagram and LinkedIn. Follow along there, or find everything in one place on our links page.


A note on what this is


This article is educational. The Money Mastery System is an educational tool, not financial software, and nothing here is legal, tax, investment or financial advice. The figures are illustrations, the growth rate is an assumption and not a forecast, and nothing here is a recommendation about any purchase or investment. For guidance on your own circumstances, please speak with a qualified professional who knows them.

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page